Instant runoff compared with other voting methods

Ranked ballots can be counted in more than one way, and different counting rules can pick different winners from the same ballots. Here are 100 voters and three candidates, counted six ways.

Last reviewed · Nonpartisan explainer · Sources linked inline

The ballots

Picture a left candidate, a centrist and a right candidate. Voters on each side rank the centrist second; centrist voters split their second choices. (Fictional numbers chosen to show the differences.)

100 ballots, three candidates
Voters1st choice2nd choice3rd choice
35LeftCenterRight
33RightCenterLeft
32CenterRightLeft
100ballots in total

Six methods, three winners

Winner under each method
MethodWinnerWhy
Plurality ("first past the post")LeftMost first choices: 35 of 100.
Two-round runoffRightLeft and Right advance; Right wins the runoff 65 to 35.
Instant runoff (ranked choice)RightCenter is eliminated first; those ballots elect Right.
Borda countCenterMost points: 132 (2 per first place, 1 per second).
Approval (top two approved)CenterApproved by 100 of 100 voters.
CondorcetCenterCenter beats each rival one on one.
Head-to-head: voters preferring the row candidate over the column candidate
vs Leftvs Centervs Right
Left—3535
Center65—67
Right6533—

The center squeeze

Center is everyone's first or second choice and would beat either rival one on one (65 to 35 against Left, 67 to 33 against Right). But Center has the fewest first choices, so instant runoff eliminates Center first:

Instant runoff on these ballots: the count, round by round
CandidateRound 1Round 2
Left 35 35.0% 35 35.0%
Center 32 32.0% out
RightWinner 33 33.0% 65 65.0%
Exhausted (no longer counting)00
Ballots still counting100100
  1. Round 1. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Left leads with 35, short of a majority. Center has the fewest votes and is eliminated. Those ballots move to their next choice: 32 to Right.
  2. Round 2. 100 ballots are counting, so a majority is 51. Right has 65 (65.0%) and wins.

This is called the center squeeze. Critics of instant runoff point to it as the method's main weakness; the Burlington, Vermont, 2009 mayoral race is the best-known real case, where analysts found the third-place finisher would have beaten each of the other two head to head (Wikipedia summary of the official results). A preprint analysis argues Alaska's 2022 special House election was another (Clelland, arXiv preprint, not peer reviewed). Supporters reply that instant runoff still produces a winner preferred by a majority over the other finalist, and that it reduces vote splitting compared with plurality, which picks Left here with just 35%.

Each method explained

Plurality (first past the post)

Mark one candidate; most votes wins, even without a majority. Simple and fast to count, and used for most U.S. elections. With three or more candidates, similar candidates can split the vote.

Two-round runoff

If no one wins a majority, the top two face each other in a second election weeks later. Used in many U.S. primaries (Georgia, Texas and others) and in France's presidential elections. Instant runoff produces a similar result in one trip, but considers more than two finalists. Turnout often changes between rounds, so the electorate in round two is different.

Instant runoff (ranked choice)

Rank candidates; eliminate the last place and transfer until someone has a majority of continuing ballots. Full explanation.

Single transferable vote

The multi-winner version of ranked choice, aiming for proportional results. How STV works.

Borda count

Points by position: with three candidates, 2 for first, 1 for second, 0 for last. Named for Jean-Charles de Borda, whose proposal dates to the 1780s (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). It rewards broad support but is vulnerable to "burying" — ranking a strong rival last on purpose. Variations are used in a few national elections, such as Nauru's parliament, and widely in sports awards and polls.

Approval voting

Mark every candidate you approve of; most approvals wins (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). It uses a different ballot, so the "top two approved" column above is an assumption, not a fact about these voters. St. Louis, Missouri, uses it for city elections (adopted 2020). Fargo, North Dakota, used it from 2020 until a 2025 state law, HB 1297, banned both approval and ranked-choice voting (Ballotpedia).

Condorcet methods

Compare every pair of candidates head to head; a candidate who beats all the others is the Condorcet winner, named for the Marquis de Condorcet (1785). Sometimes no such candidate exists (A beats B, B beats C, C beats A), so Condorcet methods need a rule for that case. They are rarely used for public elections.

Monotonicity and other quirks

A method is monotonic if ranking a candidate higher can never make that candidate lose. Instant runoff is not monotonic: in rare cases, more first-choice support for a winner changes who is eliminated first and costs that winner the election. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy lists the "Hare rule" (its name for instant runoff) among methods that fail this test (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Every method has some property it fails; the debate is about which failures matter most in practice.

  • Plurality fails the majority criterion in practice: with three or more candidates, the winner can be opposed by most voters.
  • Instant runoff can fail monotonicity and the Condorcet criterion, but always elects a candidate a majority prefers to the other finalist.
  • Borda can elect someone other than a candidate with a majority of first choices.
  • Approval ignores degrees of preference among approved candidates.

Arrow's theorem, in one line

Economist Kenneth Arrow proved that no ranked voting rule with three or more candidates can satisfy a short list of reasonable-sounding fairness conditions all at once (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Choosing a voting method means choosing which trade-offs to accept.