The idea
Voters rank candidates exactly as in a single-winner race. Instead of needing a majority, a candidate needs a quota, a number of votes that only as many candidates as there are seats can reach. Two kinds of transfers fill the seats:
- Surplus transfers. When a candidate passes the quota, the extra votes are not wasted; they move to those voters' next choices.
- Eliminations. When no one can be elected, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots move on, as in instant runoff.
The system is often called the "Hare system" after Thomas Hare, who published it in Britain in 1857 and 1859; Carl Andræ had devised a similar method in Denmark a few years earlier (Britannica). See the history page.
The Droop quota
Most STV systems use the Droop quota: (valid votes ÷ (seats + 1)) + 1, ignoring any fraction (Britannica). With 100 votes and 3 seats, the quota is 100 ÷ 4 + 1 = 26. Four candidates can't all reach 26 of 100 votes, so at most three can be elected on quota.
A three-seat example
One hundred voters, five candidates, three seats, quota 26. (Fictional numbers.)
| Voters | 1st choice | 2nd choice | 3rd choice |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 | Ana | Ben | — |
| 11 | Ben | Ana | Cara |
| 20 | Cara | Dev | — |
| 15 | Dev | Cara | — |
| 14 | Eli | Dev | — |
| 100 | ballots in total | ||
| Candidate | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ana | 40 — elected | 26 | 26 | 26 |
| Ben | 11 | 25 | 25 | 25 — elected |
| Cara | 20 | 20 | 21.55 | out |
| Dev | 15 | 15 | 29 — elected → 26 | 26 |
| Eli | 14 | 14 | out | out |
| Exhausted | 0 | 0 | 1.45 | 23 |
- Round 1. Ana has 40, over the quota of 26: elected, with a surplus of 14.
- Round 2. Ana's surplus moves. All 40 of Ana's ballots list Ben next, so each moves at 14/40 = 0.35 of a vote: Ben gains 14 and reaches 25. No one else reaches the quota.
- Round 3. Eli, in last place with 14, is eliminated. All 14 Eli ballots list Dev next, so Dev reaches 29: elected, surplus 3. Dev's 29 ballots move at 3/29 each: 15 of them list Cara next (Cara gains about 1.55); the 14 that came from Eli list no one else, so about 1.45 votes are exhausted.
- Round 4. One seat left, two candidates: Ben (25) and Cara (21.55). Cara is eliminated; her ballots list only candidates already elected, so they are exhausted. Ben takes the last seat.
Result: Ana, Dev and Ben. The 51 voters who preferred Ana or Ben won two seats; the 49 who preferred Cara, Dev or Eli won one. Under a "vote for three, most votes wins" rule, a 51% bloc voting together can win all three seats.
How surplus votes move
Different places move surpluses differently. Ireland's national elections have traditionally picked a sample of whole ballots to transfer; Scotland's council elections and the Australian Senate move every ballot at a fractional value, as in the example above (the "Gregory" method and its refinements). Fractional methods give the same result on every recount; random sampling can, rarely, differ.
Where STV is used
- Ireland: the Dáil since the 1922 general election; Irish voters twice rejected switching to first-past-the-post in referendums, in 1959 (51.8% no) and 1968 (60.8% no) (Government of Ireland referendum results). Ireland's presidential election uses the same rules with one seat, which makes it instant runoff.
- Malta: parliamentary elections by STV since 1921 (ICPSR election data).
- Australia: the federal Senate since 1949 (Australian Electoral Commission), plus several state upper houses and Tasmania's lower house.
- Scotland: council elections since 2007.
- Northern Ireland: Assembly and local elections.
- New Zealand: some local councils since 2004, by local choice.
- United States: Cambridge, Massachusetts, has elected its city council and school committee by STV since 1941; several U.S. cities used it in the early 20th century and later repealed it (Wikipedia overview). Portland, Oregon, began electing its city council from multi-member districts with ranked ballots in 2024.
STV vs. instant runoff
| Instant runoff (IRV) | Single transferable vote (STV) | |
|---|---|---|
| Seats | One | Several |
| Winning threshold | Majority of continuing ballots | Quota (Droop: votes ÷ (seats + 1), + 1) |
| Surplus transfers | Not needed | Yes |
| Goal | A broadly acceptable single winner | Seats roughly in proportion to support |
| Examples | Australia's House, Maine, Alaska, NYC primaries | Ireland, Malta, Australian Senate, Cambridge MA |